GEC Statement on the Publication “The association between early career informal mentorship in academic collaborations and junior author performance”

December 16, 2020

A recent publication in Nature Communications by Bedoor AlShebli et al. (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-19723-8) reported a very disturbing finding that women who were mentored during their PhD training primarily by women (not only thesis advisors but also collaborators) and co-authored papers with senior female compared to male scientists, received fewer citations of their work once they became independent scientists than those mentored by male scientists.  Moreover, data showed that female mentors similarly “suffer” a lower number of citations of papers co-authored with their female trainees than male trainees. Other than the criticism that can be imposed on these data for limiting the mentoring outcome to the success in publishing, this report should serve as another wake-up call to the continuing gender bias in how female scientists and their work are treated by male-dominated review panels and editorial boards. Unfortunately, the authors appear to have chosen to use their data to recommend against female mentors, for which the Gender Equality Committee (GEC) of the International Union of Immunological Societies (IUIS) believes they, as well the Nature Communications editors, need to publicly apologize to all women scientists and mentors who have fought this bias for many years and should be supported in that fight rather than brought down by additional biases.

More News

Visit the IUIS Booth at the IUIS 2025 Congress!

July 29, 2025

A message from IUIS President, Dr Miriam Merad

July 2, 2025

Congratulations to the Winners of the 2025 Day of Immunology Awards

June 30, 2025

Is there an IEI you want to see in the next IUIS IEI classification? Submit it to us now!

June 16, 2025Inborn Errors of Immunity Committee (IEI)

Meet the IUIS 2025 Rising Stars!

June 12, 2025Early Career Committee (ECC)

Teaching Sustainable Development Goals: Methods for Education

May 20, 2025Immunotherapy Committee (ITH), Education Committee (EDU)

Apply Now: Michelson Prizes – $150,000 Grants for Emerging Leaders in Immunology

May 13, 2025Early Career Committee (ECC)

Announcing the 2025 Excellence in Immunology Award Winner: Dr. Arlene Sharpe

May 5, 2025Gender Equity Committee (GEC)

IUIS Invites Bids to Host the 21st Congress of the International Union of Immunological Societies (IUIS2031)

April 29, 2025